Brown sugar is "molasses sugar," which is made by boiling down the juice of sugar cane to remove the water and hardening the molasses without separating it.
However, the main ingredient is sucrose, which has many similarities with refined sugar in terms of sweetness and effect on blood sugar levels, so care must be taken in how, how much, and how often it is used to take advantage of its "gentle sweetness.
Refined sugar has the advantage of clean appearance and flavor and ease of processing, but brown sugar may have a relatively lower impact on the body in terms of flavor, flavor depth, and mineral supply. If you are looking for a sweetness that is gentle on the body, using a moderate amount of brown sugar is a viable option.
This is the kind of article we want people to read:
People who like sweets but have health concerns about using a lot of white sugar.
People who want to adopt "natural sweetness" such as brown sugar, cane sugar, etc.
People who want to choose sweeteners while being concerned about sugar, blood sugar, and nutritional value.
Six points of comparison
(1) Difference in manufacturing process (containing molasses vs. refining)
(2) Main and non-sugar components (minerals, vitamins, molasses, etc.)
(iii) Differences in taste, flavor, richness, and aroma
(4) Differences in blood glucose, GI, and sweetness perception
(5) Health effects (mineral supplementation, nutritional value, risk of overdose)
(6) Usage, cooking, seasoning, and use in food and beverage
Difference in manufacturing process
brown cane sugarA kind of molasses sugar: sugarcane is pressed to obtain juice, which is then boiled down after removing some impurities, and the molasses is solidified or powdered without being separated. It is a type of molasses containing sugar, and a relatively high amount of molasses and minerals remain.
Refined sugar (white sugar, granulated sugar, etc.)Sucrose: Sucrose purity is obtained by taking the juice from sugar cane (or sugar beets, etc.) and subjecting it to a process of filtration, impurity removal, sugar crystallization, and molasses separation. By scraping off excess color, flavor, and trace elements, the product obtains a less peculiar appearance, preservability, and taste.
Main and non-sugar components
The main ingredient in both is sucrose, which is the source of their sweetness, and their energy and blood glucose-elevating properties are common in this regard.
Brown sugar contains minerals (calcium, potassium, iron, magnesium, etc.), which are rarely found in refined sugar, and a small amount of B vitamins (B1, B2, B6, etc.) and non-sugar components (invert sugar and molasses components). These are some of the reasons for the "body-friendly sweetness.
Refined sugar has almost all of these ingredients removed, so it generally has very little nutritional value other than sweetness (almost no minerals or vitamins).
Difference in taste, flavor and richness
brown cane sugarThe molasses content is still present in the wine, giving it a rich, deep, slightly savory, non-sweet "flavor". Other flavor nuances (caramelized, burnt, mineral astringency, etc.) can be detected.
refined sugarIt is suitable for dishes, confectionery, and beverages where flavor is not important, as it has little peculiarity, a clean sweetness, and does not interfere with the flavor. Suitable for simple sweetening.
Differences in blood sugar and sweetness perception
In terms of the intensity of sweetness and satisfaction, many people feel that brown sugar is more satisfying even in small amounts. This is because the non-sugar components and flavors enhance the sweetness, and there is a complexity that goes beyond sweetness alone.
However, since the mechanism of blood glucose increase is common in that sucrose is the main ingredient, brown sugar does not necessarily raise blood glucose levels. Sweetness, quantity, and combination with other ingredients are crucial.
Health Effects, Nutritional Value, and Risk of Overdose
Brown sugar is superior to refined sugar in terms of mineral supply, and there are examples of its relatively high calcium, iron, and potassium content, among others. For example, there are data showing that brown sugar contains significantly more calcium and potassium than 100g of refined sugar.
However, the "amount of minerals that can be supplemented with brown sugar" is only a supplement. If used in large quantities, it will result in excessive sugar and calories, so it is important to use it as a sweetener "in small quantities and infrequently.
Refined sugar has lower nutritional value, but has advantages in terms of ease of use, less peculiar taste, and ease of storage and adjustment. This is the reason why white sugar, top white sugar, etc. are chosen for some applications.
Usage and use in cooking
brown cane sugarBest for: dishes that require richness (simmered dishes, teriyaki, drinks, ginger tea, etc.) and desserts where you want to bring out the full flavor. Because of its strong flavor, it is best to use a smaller amount to balance the taste and influence the color.
refined sugarUseful for: baking pastries to maintain a white appearance, beverages, tea, coffee, and other situations where you do not want to interfere with the flavor. Suitable for dishes where you want to keep the sweetness clear.
summary
| point of view | brown cane sugar | Refined sugar (e.g., white sugar) |
|---|---|---|
| main ingredient | Mainly sucrose, but contains relatively high amounts of minerals, B vitamins, and molasses components other than sucrose | Mainly sucrose only, few impurities and trace elements |
| nutritional value | Mineral and non-sugar components remain and may be a supplemental nutrient source | Low nutritional value, sweetness/energy source only is its main role |
| Taste & Flavor | Deep, rich, and flavorful. Taste nuances not just sweetness. | Less peculiar and clean sweetness |
| Blood sugar and sweetness | May increase satisfaction with sweetness. Effect on blood glucose depends on amount and frequency. | Blood glucose rise is proportional to sweetness, but the taste factor is less variable, making it easier to use. |
| Suitable Applications | Cooking and desserts that emphasize flavor and health-conscious use of sweeteners | For confectionery that requires a beautiful white finish, when appearance is important, or when you want to reduce the peculiarity of sweetness |
If you are looking for "body-friendly sweetness," there are good reasons to use brown sugar. However, the main premise is to remember its role as a sweetener and its sugar content, and to observe the proper amount.
Japanese 
English 
Chinese (Taiwan) 
Chinese (China) 
Korean 
Indonesian 
French