What is the difference between brown sugar and molasses? A Thorough Comparison of Easily Confused Sweeteners

This is the kind of article we want people to read:
People who are trying to use either molasses or brown sugar and are not sure which to use.
People who want to know the difference of sweetness, richness, flavor, and nutrition, and use them in recipes and daily seasoning.
People who want to compare the health benefits and ingredients of brown sugar and molasses to determine "which is better".

Comparison points (key points of difference between brown sugar and molasses)

Differences in raw materials and manufacturing methods

brown cane sugarBrown sugar is a solid or powdered product made by taking the juice of sugarcane, neutralizing, precipitating and otherwise removing impurities, boiling and concentrating it, and then making it solid or powdered without separating the molasses. Under the Japanese definition, the Consumer Affairs Agency's labeling rules clarify that products that have been processed to separate the molasses without going through this process cannot be labeled as "brown sugar.

brown sugar syrupSweetened syrup made from raw materials containing brown sugar or sugar equivalent to brown sugar in liquid form. It is made by boiling and dissolving sugarcane sugar solution or brown sugar and then boiling it down to a thicker consistency. In some cases, it may contain additives or mixed ingredients.

Shape and moisture content

brown cane sugarSolid (lumps and powders), often with low moisture content and high density. Due to low water/liquid content, shelf life is relatively high, and flavor and richness are intense.

brown sugar syrup: Because it is a liquid syrup, it has a high water content, viscosity and fluidity. Easier to handle and mix with other ingredients than solids.

Difference in sweetness, richness and flavor

brown cane sugar: Deeply sweet, often with a caramel-like burnt flavor, richness and astringency. The solidity of the product allows you to savor the flavors in your mouth.

brown sugar syrupThe sweetness is smooth, and the water content speeds up the "sweetness transfer." Also, because it is liquid, it is easy to spread the flavor by pouring or mixing. The richness of the brown sugar remains, but there is less "chewing and holding" sensation than when the product is solid.

Comparison of Nutritional Components

brown cane sugarIt is rich in minerals (calcium, iron, potassium, magnesium, etc.) and has nutritional value as "molasses" because the molasses content is still present.

brown sugar syrupBrown Sugar: Often contains minerals derived from brown sugar, but the mineral content may be diluted compared to solid brown sugar due to the addition of water, boiling, and heating during the process of making it into liquid form.

Comparison of calories and carbohydrates

brown cane sugar: Solid brown sugar tends to have a higher energy density (calories and carbohydrates) per weight due to its lower water content.

brown sugar syrupThe calories and carbohydrate content may be slightly lower than the same "weight" because it is liquid and contains water. However, the difference is not so great for high density molasses. If sweetness is important, be aware that calories and carbohydrates vary depending on the "amount".

Differences in preservation and usage

brown cane sugarSolid: Easy to store for a long period of time as long as moisture and mold are taken care of. Granular and powdered forms are easy to adjust in terms of measuring, heating, and mixing with ingredients.

brown sugar syrupLiquid: Since it is a liquid, it is prone to water separation and crystallization during storage, so it is important to keep storage containers tightly closed and temperature controlled. Often used as a sauce for finishing or pouring over food. Suitable for desserts, toppings, beverage mixing, etc.

Points for proper selection and use

1) If you want to enjoy the richness of solids and "chewy sweetness," brown sugar is the one for you. For cooking and baked goods, etc., where you want to "boil down" the sugar.
(2) If you want to add sweetness in liquid form, pour it over or mix it, or add flavor to the finish, use molasses. It is suitable for topping ice cream, yogurt, zenzai, etc.
(3) If nutrition is important, brown sugar is often chosen, but molasses can also provide sufficient minerals if good quality is chosen. Check the labeling of ingredients and the presence of additives.

summary